Weak Dushthana Lords are good?

So, just to bring some more clarity to what I was saying yesterday about "If Dushthana Lords and Malefic Planets should be weak in chart?"

To understand this, 1st we need to understand what all things a planet can represent in your chart?

1. Karaka - Every planet is karaka of dozens of things like Venus represents relationship, partner, wealth, service, conveniences etc all at once.

2. House Ruler - Then every planet rules a certain house in your chart. Besides Sun and Moon, all other visible planets rule at least 2 houses. So, your dushthana lord may not be a lord of dushthana house only. It may rule some other house which can be Kendra or Trikona or Family/Relationship oriented.

3. Then some planets may also be sitting in Dushthana Houses and their way of functioning can depend of strength or weakness of Dushthana Lords.

4. A Dushthana Lord would also be sitting in some other house and would impact functioning of that particular house.

5. Then every planet owns some nakshatra and its strength or weakness is going to impact the performance of the planets which is in those nakshatras.

Now, if we take malefic planets too -

6. Malefic planets represent hard ship and troubles but every malefic planet represents some things which are very necessary to live a good life. Saturn represents Bones and Teeth, Mars represents our will power and courage, Rahu is actually our materiastic desires.

7. So, if we really say and wish that a Dushthana Lord or a Malefic Planet should be weak in chart then actually we are conceding that we are fine with all the above representations of that particular planet to be weak.

8. Like, being a Scorpio ascendant, 1st house lord Mars is also my 6th house lord. Now, if I wish that my Mars should be weak then actually I want to lose my life path (1st house), possibility of real estate, lack of will power and courage, weak immune system and ability to fight against adverse situations in life. So, my dushthana lord is not only a dushthana lord. It represents a truck-load of things. If the planet goes down then everything represented by it can go down.

9. Then if we apply this logic on malefic planets then also it doesn't work. Suppose I have a weak Saturn then it may even impact my longevity as Saturn represents the time we spend in this world. Saturn also represents Bones and Teeth. So, we can imagine how much of hard work I can put with weak bones, teeth or overall body.

10. . But even then, does it even work in reality and experience that weakness of Dushthana Lords and Malefic Planets are going to help us in leading a good and less miserable life? I don’t think so as we have example of Helen Keller - https://www.astrosaxena.com/Keller , who had Saturn debilitated in 6th house/Aries and 6th house lord Mars debilitated in 9th house/Cancer. So, Dushthana 6th house cannot get weaker than this and both visible malefic planets are weak in chart. But we all know that she lived a life of life-long illnesses (6th house) and although she achieved great things in her life but it was possible because of the continuous support from people around her.

So, this is what I wanted to say that ideally, every planet should be in good dignity because at least person will remain on his own and there will be strong will-power and courage to fight with adverse situations of life.

Hope this helps. Thanks,

SPB